
How to Choose Church Fund Accounting Software
Vendors say fund accounting. Run one real month through a free plan or trial instead: six transactions to test and what each should show.
Church fund accounting software keeps a separate balance for each fund, so you can show the board what's left for missions, the building and the general fund, and which of those dollars donors restricted. To choose one, don't compare feature lists. Run one real month of your own transactions through a free plan or trial and check six results.
What is church fund accounting software?
It's an accounting system where the fund is part of every entry. One checking account can hold several funds at once, so the ledger has to know which dollars belong where, and every journal entry has to balance within each fund.
Churches end up tracking funds in one of three ways. Only the first is fund accounting:
- A fund ledger. Each fund has its own balance on the books. "How much is left in the building fund?" is a report, not a project.
- Classes or tags in business software. They slice a profit-and-loss report, but they don't keep a balance for each fund. A Reddit user who runs QuickBooks Online for a midsize church described the result: "The classes in QBO don't carry to the balance sheet, so that's why I make one big AJE at month end."
- A spreadsheet. The purpose of each gift lives in a tab, with no balanced entry behind it.
Classes also blur the line nonprofit accounting rules draw between donor money and board money. FASB's 2016 update for nonprofits (ASU 2016-14) has the statement of financial position (the nonprofit balance sheet) show two groups of net assets: with donor restrictions and without donor restrictions. Money your board set aside on its own, such as an operating reserve, stays on the "without" side, and the same update asks you to disclose those board designations. A "Reserve" class can hold a donor's restricted building gift right next to money the board only hoped to save, and nothing on the report tells them apart.
Count your funds before you start, so you know what the test has to cover. Among churches using Grain, a typical church tracks about 6 funds and 1 in 3 tracks 10 or more. 7 in 10 track at least one donor-restricted fund, and about 1 in 4 has a board-designated fund (anonymized Grain data, 2026 so far). If you want the basics of how funds work first, start with fund accounting for churches.
What should a church look for in accounting software?
Most buyer's guides agree on the list: fund accounting, giving that flows into the books, bank reconciliation, giving statements, board reports, payroll and a price that fits. They're right. The trouble is that a list of seven features can't tell you which product will save you work at month end. Your own transactions can, and you want that answer before you've moved a year of books in.
How do you test church accounting software with one real month?
Pick last month. Pull its bank statement, its giving deposits, one week's offering count sheet, a few bills and last month's board report. Then enter these six things in the free plan or trial and check what you get back.
Use real numbers, including the messy ones. Among churches using Grain, 31% of giving dollars arrive by check and 14% in cash, nearly half together (anonymized Grain data, 2026 so far). A test that only uses online gifts skips the deposits that take the most work.
| # | Enter this | A pass looks like | Red flag |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | An online gift split between the general fund and missions | One gift, two fund balances updated, with the donor still attached | You split it by hand, or the donor record and the books disagree |
| 2 | A Sunday deposit with cash, checks and one designated gift | The deposit total matches the count sheet and the bank, and the designated gift lands in its fund | You type the deposit twice: once for giving, once for the books |
| 3 | Two bills paid from a restricted fund, one of them more than the fund holds | The fund balance drops, and the software tells you before the second bill takes it below zero | The bill posts without a word, and you find out at the board meeting |
| 4 | The month's bank reconciliation, with online gifts deposited after the processor takes its fees | Each deposit matches the bank, with the fees recorded as an expense | Deposits never match, so you reconcile "close enough" |
| 5 | A year-to-date statement for a donor who gave $250 or more at once | The statement total equals what the ledger shows for that donor | Two numbers, and no way to see which one is right |
| 6 | Last month's board report | Fund balances, income and spending by fund, budget against actual, and any total opens to the entries behind it | You export to Excel to build the report the board actually reads |
On test 5: a donor needs a written acknowledgment from the church for any single gift of $250 or more to claim the deduction, and one annual statement can cover several of them. If the giving statement and the ledger can drift apart, you'll find out when a donor calls in February.
Test 6 is the one you'll repeat every month. If you want something to compare against, our free church treasurer report template builds a board report in Excel.
If the software fails test 1 or test 6, stop there. Those are the two jobs you're buying it for.
Who should be able to do what in the books?
Software can't count the offering for you, but it should make your controls easy to keep. CPA Mike Batts, quoted in Church Law & Tax's internal-controls guidance, puts the rule plainly: "Live funds must be processed by at least two unrelated people working together." The same article adds: "Separate those who handle money from those who manage accounting and reporting."
So, during the test month, check three logins:
- An approver. Can a pastor or committee chair see budgets and reports and approve bills without being able to post entries?
- The board. Can board members see reports and fund balances without edit rights?
- Your outside accountant. Can they get read-only access at year end, without you exporting files for them?
What should you ask before you sign?
Ask the vendor three questions, and get the answers in writing:
- What will it cost at our size, all in? Find the number the price depends on (expenses, revenue, members or users), then add bank accounts, users, payroll and anything sold as an add-on.
- How do our books get in, and how do they get out? Ask who moves your history and opening fund balances, and in what file format you can take everything with you if you leave.
- Does it connect to the giving platform we're keeping? If people and giving live in Planning Center or Pushpay, look for software that brings those deposits in, not one that asks you to move your member records too.
How does Grain handle these six tests?
Grain Ledger is built around these jobs. Its fund accounting is part of the ledger, with restricted and unrestricted balances and fund balance reports that show net asset changes. Giving comes in from Planning Center, Pushpay, Rock RMS, Subsplash, OnlineGiving.org and Overflow. Pushpay and Overflow also send the cash and check batches you record there. The bank comes in through Plaid. When a bill or expense would take a restricted fund below zero, Grain warns you. Giving statements carry the IRS disclosures, and reports open from any total to the journal entries behind it. All three logins exist: an approver who can't post entries, and read-only access for the board and your outside accountant.
The Starter plan is free, not a trial, for churches with up to $20,000 a month in expenses, with unlimited funds and no credit card. That's enough room to run all six tests on your own books. Growth is $70 a month for churches with up to $1 million a year in revenue or expenses, and payroll is $50 a month plus $10 per employee on any plan. Migration help from QuickBooks, Aplos, ParishSoft and spreadsheets is free, and the church accounting software page walks through the rest.
Frequently asked questions
Is QuickBooks fund accounting software?
No. QuickBooks is general business accounting. Churches that use it track funds with classes, which slice a profit-and-loss report but don't carry a balance for each fund to the balance sheet. If you're moving off it, every Grain plan includes one-click QuickBooks migration, the free Starter plan too.
Does a small church need fund accounting if it doesn't file a Form 990?
Yes, if it takes gifts for a specific purpose. Churches don't have to file Form 990 (IRS Publication 1828), so the board report is the main financial report the software produces, and it has to show those funds.
Ready to simplify your church finances?
Start free with church fund accounting, or watch a product demo first.